High definition editing from the trenches...

Shane Ross is a broadcast television editor who works with HD. This is the place he shares his experiences editing high definition television shows and lets you know about the good things and the bad, hoping you can learn from his mistakes and successes. Shane is also available for hire as a consultant. comeback@mac.com

Tuesday, October 23, 2007

LEOPARD & FINAL CUT PRO

The new version of Mac OSX is due out on October 26...Leopard. To install, or not to install, THAT is the question.

Now...those of you with editing systems should proceed with caution. I always, repeat ALWAYS say, "if you have a stable working system, DO NOT UPDATE IT!" Having a stable working editing system is the key to a smooth running business, a stress free life, and more time you can devote to reading, riding your bike, playing with the kids...ANYTHING but sitting in your office for hours trying to figure out what went wrong.

OK, if you find that you MUST update your system and play with all the new toys it has to offer, I have a few suggestions to make to cover your butt:

1) CLONE YOUR SYSTEM DRIVE. Get Carbon Clopy Cloner and an external firewire drive that is as big as your internal, and clone your nice, clean, WORKING system onto it. This way, if things don't work out with leopard, you can always go back to your properly working system.

2) GET A NEW HARD DRIVE AND INSTALL ON THAT. Now, this only works if you have a MacPro or G5, or G4...a tower where you can swap out drives. I listed the other option first because anyone can do that, towers, laptops, iMacs, MacMinis. This is the cheaper way to go as internal SATA drives are cheaper than firewire drives. Pop out the current system drive and pop in this new drive. Or, if you happen to have an open drive slot, install this in there, so you can have a DUAL BOOT system. Working system, NEW system. Then boot up on the Leopard Install disk and jump through the installing hoops.

Well, that about covers it. Oh, wait...you DON'T want to spend money on another hard drive? Well, OK, if you don't have $80 to spend on a 250Gb internal, or lacking the funds to buy a $200 external FW 250GB drive....because getting Leopard tapped you out...then this is what you can do. Mind you, it'll not be nearly as slick as the other options.

Back up all your files. Project files, work documents, spreadsheets, pictures, movies, music...you should be doing this anyway. If you don't have a back up drive...what the heck are you thinking?!?! Ahem, anyway, then erase your system drive and install Leopard from scratch. Yeah, you can install Leopard on top of Tiger, but this way you ENSURE that you will have a clean, fresh OS. Then install all your applications and copy back all your files.

OH...and the most important thing I can stress: Do not upgrade while you are in the middle of a project. I cannot stress this enough. If the upgrade messes things up, then you have downtime. And downtime is a killer...because in the editing world there are deadlines. Now, if you are NEVER in the middle of a project, and have several that overlap (I know several people and places this applies to), do the upgrade when you can spare the time to do it, test it, and fix it if things don't work. Weekends are good for this, or any time you can spare a couple days, or have a few days down time and it not be a burden.

But really...honestly...what I'd REALLY suggest you do?

Wait.

Wait and let others install Leopard and find all the issues with it. OR, if you have TWO computers, one you use for work and then another one you use for web surfing and e-mail...install Leopard on that one. The biggest thing I want to get across is that if you are using a machine to earn a living, and it is working fine...don't do something that might cause it not to work. You need to eat.

OK...the time is approaching. Friday will soon be upon us and Leopard will come out.

And I swear, 4 minutes later there will be a post on one of the FCP forums where someone says, "I just installed Leopard, and now I can't _______ in FCP. HEEEEELLLLPPP!"

Don't be that guy. Or gal.

11 comments:

WTL said...

I hear you. I'll be installing 10.5 on my main box, and if anything goes wacky, I'll be able to use my MacBook Pro until that gets sorted out.

AndrewK said...

I'm always willing to let others find all the "early adopter" bugs. :) If it ain't broke, and if no projects I'm working on would benefit from the new features, I'm more than happy to sit put.

B-Scene Films said...

Mornin Shane. I could not agree more. I keep one system with FCS 2 on it that I run updates on to see what happens. I will be installing Leopard on that machine on Saturday.

I'll blog the process and any issues that I have doing it.

Mike

Nick Schmidt said...

So how compatible is Leopard with FCP .. ???

Shane Ross said...

Mike, I'll be sure to keep up on your blog.

Nick...no one knows as Leopard isn't out yet. Tomorrow...it comes out tomorrow. And then you need to wait a day for people to install it (hopefully properly) and see what pops up on the forums.

jwdenzel said...

Hi Shane,

I have no big projects at the moment, so I updated my Mac Pro from OS 10.4 to the new Leopard 10.5

Everything went perfectly smooth. All my programs worked immediately.

- Photoshop CS3 - no problems
- AE CS3 - no problems
- Final Cut Pro Studio 2 (all apps) - no problems, including capturing HDV footage from my Canon HV20.
- iLife - no problems
- Blender 3D - no problems
- Google Earth - crashed on me the first time. So I upgraded to the latest version out there. No problems after that
- MS Word / Excel - no problems
- Vue 6 - no problems
- Poser 7 - no problems
- Frameforge 3D - no problems
- Firefox, and other misc FTP/SSH/VNC apps - no problems

That's not to say there won't be smaller problems, but all is working normal for me.

Also, I have a Blackmagic Intensity card, but I've not tested it yet. BM has a driver update for it on Leopard though, so it is probably OK to use.

Thanks for the great blog.
Jason Denzel

Helmut Kobler said...

Just FYI: Adobe has a statement about Leopard compatibility at this link:

http://www.adobe.com/support/products/pdfs/leopardsupport.pdf

Apparently, After Effects CS3 along with Premiere, Encore, and Soundbooth need an update that will come in December 07. Strange that some people are saying that AE CS3 works fine under Leopard, though. Maybe there are a few features that go haywire, but the majority of the app works....

Nick Schmidt said...

@shane & @jwdenzel

Thanks for the comments about Leopard compatible with FCP. I have the old version of FCP (not the new). I may have to download Leopard tonight (if that is available) and try it out!!

Shane Ross said...

Nick...it isn't a download. You have to buy the physical installer. It is TOO BIG for download.

Nick Schmidt said...

@shane.. oh ok.. well thanks anyway..

Anonymous said...

For what it's worth, LiveType, Soundtrack, and Final Cut Express also work.